The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) yesterday (25 August) announced it required Veolia to sell three businesses after a merger investigation concluded the merger gives rise to competition concerns in a number of markets.
The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) concluded that Veolia must sell substantial parts of the merged business:
- Suez’s UK waste management services businesses;
- Suez’s UK industrial water operation and maintenance services business; and
- Veolia’s European mobile water services business.
These businesses make up almost all of the overlap between Veolia’s and Suez’s competing operations in the UK.
In response to the provisional findings of the Phase 2 inquiry, Veolia said that it would sell the UK Suez waste business. The CMA will determine the conditions of the sale, as well as the sales of the 2 water services businesses.
Given our concerns about the merger, we have concluded that Veolia must sell most of the operations it took over in the UK when it acquired Suez
The CMA will need to approve the purchasers of each business before the completion of each sale.
Veolia and Suez are both global players in waste and water management. In 2020, the companies generated approximately £2bn and £1bn in the UK respectively – roughly 10% and 7% of their annual global revenues.
Veolia and Suez are active across the full waste management supply chain. They collect waste from households and businesses, sort it for recycling and composting and dispose of the remaining waste – some of which is incinerated to produce electricity. Many local authorities in the UK rely heavily on either Veolia or Suez to meet their waste management needs. The companies also supply water and wastewater management services to industrial customers.
The CMA says it heard from a number of councils and customers who were concerned about the potential impact of the merger on the cost and quality of the services they receive. Ultimately, taxpayers and businesses would have been left to cover any increase in cost.
“Negative impact”
Stuart McIntosh, Chair of the CMA inquiry group, said: “Local authority budgets are already under strain, and this deal is likely to lead to them paying more and receiving a lower-quality service. The negative impact would have ultimately fallen on taxpayers at a time when they are feeling the pressure of the cost of living crisis.
“Given our concerns about the merger, we have concluded that Veolia must sell most of the operations it took over in the UK when it acquired Suez. We will now work with Veolia to ensure that appropriate buyers are found so that businesses, councils – and ultimately taxpayers – will not lose out.
The CMA’s final report reiterates its provisional findings issued in May. It rules that the merger would lead to competition concerns in 5 waste markets and 2 water treatment markets.
In each of these markets, the merging businesses currently compete closely and would face limited competition after the merger.
The CMA found that this would be likely to result in higher cost or lower quality services for councils, with knock-on effects for taxpayers, as well as businesses across the UK.
Drawing a line
The CMA launched an investigation into the deal between Veolia and Suez in October 2021. The transaction was referred for an in-depth Phase 2 review, which is led by an independent inquiry group, in December 2021.
This deal has been reviewed by a number of competition authorities across the world. Major divestments were also required in the EU and in Australia, the CMA says.
John Scanlon, Chief Executive Officer for SUEZ recycling and recovery UK said: “The publication of the Competition and Markets Authority’s final decision draws a line under this chapter of our company’s history.
The publication of the Competition and Markets Authority’s final decision draws a line under this chapter of our company’s history.
“I’d like to thank the teams at the Competition and Markets Authority and Veolia, and of course my SUEZ colleagues, for their hard work and diligence during the investigation.
“With our new ownership set to be confirmed before the year is out, this will come at a pivotal moment for our sector, and I look forward to playing our part in the UK’s transition to a more resource efficient, circular economy, delivering on our commitment to People and Planet.”
Veolia is yet to issue a statement.
