YouGov survey finds ‘variable’ deposit return scheme not ‘too complex’

The majority of respondents to new YouGov research, released today (17 March), said they would not find a variable rate deposit return scheme (DRS) ‘too complex’.

Commissioned by Alupro, the aluminium packaging recycling organisation, 2,000 adults across Britain were surveyed about ‘best practice DRS design’ and whether a ‘variable’ rate deposit fee would add ‘unnecessary confusion’.

It comes as the UK Government is set to introduce a DRS covering England, Wales and Northern Ireland in 2023. The scheme will see shoppers pay a deposit on drinks containers that can be redeemed when the container is returned to a designated collection point.

Aiming to tackle plastic pollution, increase recycling rates, improve recyclate quality and minimise litter, England, Wales and Northern Ireland’s DRS is expected to come into force in 2023. Scotland is also set to launch its own DRS in 2022.

There has been much discussion over what ‘best practice’ might look like in this area, with calls for schemes that will include all materials, not just plastic, and of all sizes, and also questions about whether a ‘flat’ or ‘variable’ fee is best.

While a variable rate fee would see containers allocated with a deposit value based on container size, a flat rate model would apply a fixed fee to all beverage containers. This approach could see customers charged an additional £4.80 for a 24-can multipack (on top of product purchase price) compared to just 80p for a 2-litre plastic bottle, according to Alupro.

Scotland will go ahead with a ‘flat’ fee approach, which Zero Waste Scotland says will ‘give people a clear incentive to return all their empty bottles and cans, regardless of size’.

There is concern among some, including Alupro, that a ‘flat’ deposit fee will have ‘serious implications’ for the sale of single serve and multi-packs and risks incentivising consumers to purchase two-litre plastic bottles.

Variable system

The YouGov insight, however, suggests that 85% of Brits consider a variable system easy to understand and support ‘higher deposits for larger containers’.

More than four in five respondents suggested that the concept of a DRS was easy to grasp (84%), and that the idea of varying the deposit value based on container size was ‘equally simplistic’ (85%).

Just over half of adults (55%) agreed that the deposit fee should be lower for smaller items and higher for larger ones, while three in ten (30%) thought the deposit amount should be the same across all sizes of packaging. A small minority admitted that they were undecided (15%).

These findings contradict government research from 2019, which suggested that a variable rate would be far too complex for householders.

Rick Hindley, executive director at Alupro, commented: “Our independent research aimed to analyse real-world views regarding awareness of DRS design and understanding of deposit fees. According to the results, it’s safe to say that now, more than ever, householders want the best solution for the future – not the cheapest or the fastest.’

Privacy Overview
Circular Online

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is temporarily stored in your browser and helps our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

More information about our Cookie Policy

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly necessary cookies allow core website functionality and the website cannot be used properly without them. These cookies include session cookies and persistent cookies.

Session cookies keep track of your current visit and how you navigate the site. They only last for the duration of your visit and are deleted from your device when you close your browser.

Persistent cookies last after you’ve closed your Internet browser and enable our website to recognise you as a repeat visitor and remember your actions and preferences when you return.

Functional cookies

Third party cookies include performance cookies and targeting cookies.

Performance cookies collect information about how you use a website, e.g. which pages you go to most often, and if you get error messages from web pages. These cookies don’t collect information that identifies you personally as a visitor, although they might collect the IP address of the device you use to access the site.

Targeting cookies collect information about your browsing habits. They are usually placed by advertising networks such as Google. The cookies remember that you have visited a website and this information is shared with other organisations such as media publishers.

Keeping these cookies enabled helps us to improve our website and display content that is more relevant to you and your interests across the Google content network.

Send this to a friend